The tipping debate in America is heating up. Data shows that people often feel pressured to tip, even in places where they neverAnd because prices are so high, some people find it difficult to tip on top of everything else. Then there’s the question of whether companies should pay higher minimum wages instead of making their employees rely on tips. All of this makes tipping a problem for many.
With the presidential campaign in full swing, there is now a new debate to consider: proposals to eliminate the tip tax are gaining political support on both sides of the aisle.
No taxes on tips?
Former President Donald Trump originally proposed the idea at a rally earlier this year as a way to appeal to, some say, “working-class” voters, but several Republican lawmakers have since introduced bills to implement the policy, and it has now become a central part of campaign messages for the 2024 presidential election.
Subscribe Kiplinger’s personal finances
Be a smarter and more informed investor.
Save up to 74%
Sign up for Kiplinger’s free e-newsletter
Profit and prosper with the best expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more – delivered straight to your email inbox.
Profit and thrive with the best expert advice – straight to your email inbox.
“The hotel workers and people who get tips are going to be very happy because when I get into office, we will not tax tips,” Trump told his supporters at a rally earlier this year.
Some Democratic lawmakers, especially from states with large service industries, have also expressed interest. They are touting this as a way to provide immediate financial relief to service sector workers. For example, Democratic Senators from Nevada Jacky Roses And Catherine Cortez Masto have signed on as sponsors of a Republican-led bill to exempt tips from federal income tax.
Just recently, Vice President Kamala Harris publicly expressed her support for the idea of not taxing tips while campaigning in Nevada with vice presidential candidate and Governor Tim Walz (Democrat, Minnesota).
“If I am president, we will continue our fight for America’s working families, including raising the minimum wage and eliminating taxes on tips for service and hospitality workers,” said Harris, who Kitchen Workers’ Union supported, he said in conversation with his supporters.
The Harris campaign has reportedly made clear that such a proposal would require appropriate congressional legislation, including income limits and other requirements to prevent high-income taxpayers from gaining unfair advantages.
Still, this rare agreement between the two parties has reignited the debate over how to support service sector workers, who often struggle financially despite long hours. Both sides at least seem to recognize the potential political benefits of a policy that could affect millions of people.
But the proposal remains controversial and has a mix of potential benefits and drawbacks that politicians from both parties must grapple with. Will eliminating the tip tax help workers or actually make a difference? Here’s what you need to know.
How are tips taxed?
Under Power IRS GuidelinesTips received by employees are considered taxable income. This includes cash tips, tips received via credit or debit cards, and the value of non-cash tips such as tickets or other items. Employees must report all cash tips to their employer if the total amount of tips for the month exceeds $20.
- Employers then withhold income taxes, as well as Social Security and Medicare taxes, based on wages and reported tips.
- In addition, service charges (mandatory fees added to an invoice) are treated as regular wages by the IRS and are subject to the same tax deductions.
For this reason, those who advocate for the elimination of the tip tax point to the potential benefit of increasing the take-home pay of some workers. Not taxing tips could provide financial relief for some workers in industries such as the restaurant industry, where base wages are often low.
Another related argument is that by reducing their taxable income, workers who rely heavily on tips could have more disposable income to cover living expenses and necessities, thereby improving their financial stability.
Some data also suggests that many in the U.S. support the idea of tax-free tips. For example, a recent survey by the polling and strategy consulting firm Redfield & Wilton Strategies found that 67% of Americans (across party lines) oppose taxing service employee tips.
Abolishing the tax on tips: disadvantages?
Some economists have cited the potential loss of federal revenue associated with proposals to eliminate a tax on tips as a primary concern.
- The Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget estimates that exempting tips from income and payroll taxes could result in revenue losses of $150 to $250 billion over the next decade.
- Some say this could increase national debt and strain government resources.
Other critics argue that the policy of exempting tips from taxes may not reach those who need it most. Analysis by Yale University found that only a small portion of workers would benefit from the exemption, as many low-income earners already pay minimal or no federal income tax due to their income levels. There is also the argument that employers should increase base pay to support workers who rely on tips, and that focusing on tips could hurt efforts to increase the minimum wage.
Note: A study A study published earlier this year by researchers at the University of Michigan and Carnegie Mellon University found that raising the minimum wage can benefit both workers and businesses. The results suggest that higher wages are associated with better employee retention and higher profits for more efficient operations in the food service industry.
Another problem is the potential for abuse. Eliminating the tip tax could lead to employers reclassifying wages as tips to take advantage of tax benefits, or higher earners could unfairly exploit the tax regime without adequate safeguards such as income limits.
Opponents argue that these scenarios could lead to inequalities among low-income workers and provide an incentive for companies to prioritize tips over wage increases.
Of course there are legal hurdlesImplementing this policy would require legislative action, as Vice President Harris’ campaign acknowledged, and the proposal would have to pass a deeply divided Congress.
Tax on tips: Conclusion
The proposal to eliminate the federal tax on tips has both advantages and disadvantages. While it promises higher wages for service workers, it also brings problems because of lost revenue and the need to ensure that those who need the tax break most actually get it.
As Kamala Harris and Donald Trump court support in key swing states like Nevada, the debate over the tip tax is moving to the forefront of a broader discussion about economic justice and fiscal responsibility.
However, it remains to be seen whether the idea will ever gain enough bipartisan support in Congress to become law, so stay tuned.
Related
